Introducing the Menu: My Tomato Pie
Welcome to My Tomato Pie, nestled in Amherst, NY, where the essence of comforting Italian cuisine comes to life. The menu shines with its delicious entrees, like the Chicken Parmesan and Chicken Cacciatore, both featuring rich, flavorful sauces that sing with authenticity. Each dish is thoughtfully crafted, served over a hearty bed of spaghetti, ensuring a satisfying meal for all.
For the little ones, My Tomato Pie offers a delightful kids’ menu, featuring favorites like Kid's Macaroni & Cheese and Kid's Spaghetti, making family dining a joy. Refreshing options such as Saranac Shirley Temple and Sparkling Lemonade complement the meals perfectly.
Patrons rave about the overall experience, with customers praising both the warm atmosphere and attentive service. Come and taste the homemade quality of My Tomato Pie—sure to become your next favorite dining spot!
My Tomato Pie - Starters
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
US$12.00Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls
US$12.00Coconut Shrimp
US$14.00Hummus Pita Plate
US$10.00Mama Rose's Stuffed Hot Peppers
US$15.00Mediterranean Platter
US$15.00Nachos
US$14.00Pizza Bread
US$12.00Spinach Bread
US$10.00 My Tomato Pie - Soups
Tomato Basil Soup Bowl
US$7.00Tomato Basil Soup Large
US$10.00Vegetable Minestrone Soup Bowl
US$7.00Vegetable Minestrone Soup Large
US$10.00 My Tomato Pie - Salads
House Salad (Small)
US$8.00House Salad (Large)
US$12.00Caesar Salad (Small)
US$8.00Caesar Salad (Large)
US$12.00Cobb Salad
US$18.00Pizza Salad
US$17.00Mediterranean Salad
US$15.00Strawberries And Goat Cheese Salad
US$16.00Antoinette's Chopped Salad
US$18.00Cranberry Walnut Chicken Stuffed Tomato Salad
US$16.00Albacore Tuna Stuffed Tomato Salad
US$16.00 My Tomato Pie - Pita Sandwiches
Lemon Chicken Pita Sandwich
US$17.00Caesar Pita Sandwich
US$17.00Veggie Pita Sandwich
US$17.00Steak Pita Sandwich
US$22.00 My Tomato Pie - Wraps
Albacore Tuna Diablo Wrap
US$16.00Turkey Club Wrap
US$16.00Portobello Wrap
US$16.00Steak Wrap
US$17.00 My Tomato Pie - Focaccia Sandwiches
Albacore Tuna Melt Focaccia
US$16.00Blackened Chicken Focaccia
US$17.00Chicken Florentine Focaccia
US$17.00Chicken Focaccia
US$17.00Ham Focaccia
US$16.00Steak Portobello Focaccia
US$23.00Turkey Focaccia
US$16.00 My Tomato Pie - Sandwiches
Portobello Melt Sandwich
US$16.00Meatball Sandwich
US$16.00Steak Sandwich
US$22.00Steak Hoagie
US$16.00Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Sandwich
US$16.00 My Tomato Pie - Burgers - My Burger Bar
Classic Burger
US$18.00Bleu Burger
US$19.00Smokehouse Burger
US$19.00Spinach Burger
US$19.00 My Tomato Pie - Fish (Wednesday & Friday Only)
12oz Beer-Battered Haddock Fish Fry (Wednesday & Friday Only)
US$19.00Fish Sandwich (Wednesday & Friday Only)
US$16.00 My Tomato Pie - Fries & Rings
Cajun Tossed Fries (Basket)
US$13.00Cajun Tossed Fries (Side)
US$8.00French Fries (Basket)
US$9.00French Fries (Small)
US$5.00Loaded Fries (Basket)
US$14.00Onion Rings (Basket)
US$10.00Onion Rings (Side)
US$6.00Sweet Potato Fries (Basket)
US$10.00Sweet Potato Fries (Side)
US$6.00 My Tomato Pie - Wings & Fingers
Single Wings (10)
US$18.00Double Wings (20)
US$29.00Triple Wings (30)
US$42.00Bucket Wings (50)
US$65.00Chicken Fingers (4)
US$13.00Chicken Fingers (7)
US$20.00Chicken Fingers (10)
US$25.00Chicken Fingers (20)
US$45.00 My Tomato Pie - Entrees
Chicken Parmesan
US$24.00Chicken Cacciatore
US$24.00Sausage Cacciatore
US$24.00Eggplant Parmesan
US$22.00House Salad (Small)
US$9.00Caesar Salad (Small)
US$10.00 My Tomato Pie - Pasta
Cheese Ravioli
US$19.00Chicken Piccata
US$26.00Lobster Ravioli
US$24.00Mac & Cheese
US$18.00Mama Rose's Restaurant Spaghetti
US$14.00Mama Rose's Restaurant Spaghetti (Side)
US$12.00Pasta Maria
US$23.00Shrimp Scampi
US$27.00Spaghetti Parmesan
US$16.50Tomato Cream Penne
US$24.00Tossed Penne
US$14.00Traditional Bolognese
US$28.00Zesty Chicken Pasta
US$24.00House Salad (Small)
US$9.00Caesar Salad (Small)
US$10.00 My Tomato Pie - Gluten Free Pasta
Gluten Free Tossed Penne
US$17.00Gluten Free Chicken Cacciatore
US$24.00Gluten Free Sausage Cacciatore
US$24.00Gluten-Free Mediterranean Pasta
US$20.00 My Tomato Pie - Calzones
Build Your Own Calzone
US$11.00Chicken Calzone
US$19.00Chicken Finger Calzone
US$20.00Chicken Parmesan Calzone
US$18.00Hawaiian Calzone
US$16.00Meat Lovers Calzone
US$19.00Meatball Calzone
US$18.00Philly Steak Calzone
US$19.00Portobello Calzone
US$19.00Sausage Calzone
US$16.00Vegetable Calzone
US$18.00 My Tomato Pie - Pinsa
Pinsa Antonio
US$27.00Pinsa Bella Rosa
US$27.00Pinsa Caprese
US$21.00Pinsa Carissa
US$28.00Pinsa Cheese Steak
US$28.00Pinsa Chicken Finger
US$28.00Pinsa Cruciano
US$27.00Pinsa Felice
US$27.00Pinsa Hawaiian
US$24.00Pinsa Lucca
US$27.00Pinsa Nicholas
US$25.00Pinsa Nina
US$22.00Pinsa Rebecca
US$24.00Pinsa Sergio
US$27.00Pinsa Sicilian
US$20.00Pinsa Viaggio
US$24.00 My Tomato Pie - Kids Meals
Kid's Fingers And Fries
US$8.50Kid's Macaroni & Cheese
US$8.50Kid's Spaghetti With Butter
US$8.50Kid's Spaghetti With Mama Rose's Restaurant Sauce
US$8.50Kid's Teeny Tomato Pie
US$8.50 My Tomato Pie - Desserts
Apple Crisp A La Mode
US$7.50Chocolate Chunk Cookie (4oz)
US$2.50Chocolate Decadent Torte (Gluten Free)
US$7.50Chocolate Lava Cake
US$8.50Colossal NY Style Cheesecake
US$8.00Lemon Italian Cream Cake
US$8.00Vanilla Ice Cream - 2 Scoops
US$4.00Snickerdoodle Cookie (4oz)
US$3.00Peanut Butter Cookie
US$3.00 My Tomato Pie - Extras
Chicken Breast (6oz) (Piece)
US$6.00Coleslaw (5oz Side)
US$2.50Coleslaw (Quart)
US$5.99Dressing (2.5oz)
US$1.00Dressing (Pint)
US$6.00Dressing (Quart)
US$9.00Extra Bleu Cheese (2.5oz)
US$1.25Extra Ranch (2.5oz)
US$0.75Extra Side
US$2.50Extra Wing Sauce (2.5oz)
US$1.00Garlic Bread Stick
US$1.00Hot Sauce (2.5oz)
US$1.00Mama Rose's Sauce (8oz)
US$3.00Mama Rose's Sauce (Quart)
US$9.00Marinara Sauce (2.5oz)
US$1.00Marinara Sauce (Quart)
US$9.00Mayo (2.5oz)
US$0.75Meatball (Piece)
US$2.50Pesto (2.5oz)
US$1.00Pita Med Style
US$4.00Pizza Crust (5)
US$5.00Salsa (2.5oz)
US$0.75Side - Red Sauce (2.5oz)
US$1.00Sour Cream (2.5oz)
US$0.75Tartar Sauce (2.5oz)
US$0.75 My Tomato Pie - Your Tomato Pies (Build Your Own Pizza)
Pizza Bread
US$13.00Personal 7" Pizza
US$8.00Small 12" Pizza
US$16.00Large 16" Pizza
US$22.00Gluten Free 10" Pizza
US$15.00 My Tomato Pie - Personal Specialty
Personal Antonio Pizza
US$12.00Personal Bella Rosa Pizza
US$12.00Personal Caprese Pizza
US$10.00Personal Carissa Pizza
US$12.00Personal Cheese Steak Pizza
US$13.00Personal Chicken Finger
US$12.00Personal Cruciano
US$12.00Personal Felice
US$12.00Personal Hawaiian
US$11.00Personal Lucca
US$12.00Personal Nicholas
US$11.00Personal Nina
US$10.00Personal Rebecca
US$11.00Personal Sergio
US$12.00Personal Sicilian
US$10.00Personal Viaggio
US$11.00 My Tomato Pie - Small Specialty
Small Antonio
US$25.00Small Bella Rosa
US$25.00Small Caprese
US$19.00Small Carissa
US$26.00Small Cheese Steak Pizza
US$26.00Small Chicken Finger
US$26.00Small Cruciano
US$25.00Small Felice
US$25.00Small Hawaiian
US$22.00Small Lucca
US$25.00Small Nicholas
US$23.00Small Nina
US$20.00Small Rebecca
US$22.00Small Sergio
US$25.00Small Sicilian
US$18.00Small Viaggio
US$22.00 My Tomato Pie - Large Specialty
Large Antonio
US$31.00Large Bella Rosa
US$31.00Large Caprese
US$26.00Large Carissa
US$33.00Large Cheese Steak Pizza
US$33.00Large Chicken Finger
US$32.00Large Cruciano
US$31.00Large Felice
US$31.00Large Hawaiian
US$28.00Large Lucca
US$31.00Large Nicholas
US$29.00Large Nina
US$25.00Large Rebecca
US$28.00Large Sergio
US$31.00Large Sicilian
US$25.00Large Viaggio
US$28.00 My Tomato Pie - Gluten-Free Specialty
Gluten-Free Antonio
US$24.50Gluten-Free Bella Rosa
US$24.50Gluten-Free Caprese
US$19.00Gluten-Free Carissa
US$23.50Gluten-Free Felice
US$24.50Gluten-Free Hawaiian
US$21.50Gluten-Free Nicholas
US$23.00Gluten-Free Nina
US$19.50Gluten-Free Rebecca
US$21.50Gluten-Free Sergio
US$24.50Gluten-Free Sicilian
US$18.00Gluten-Free Viaggio
US$21.50 My Tomato Pie - 2L Bottle Beverages
Pepsi (2L)
US$4.00Diet Pepsi (2L)
US$4.00Brisk Iced Tea Lemon (2L)
US$4.50Starry (2L)
US$4.50 My Tomato Pie - Bottled/Canned Beverages
Aquafina Water (20oz)
US$2.50Aunt Rosie's Loganberry (12oz)
US$2.00Brisk Iced Tea Lemon (20oz)
US$3.00Diet Pepsi (20oz)
US$3.00Mtn Dew (20oz)
US$3.00Pepsi (20oz)
US$3.00Pure Leaf Sweet Tea (18.5oz)
US$3.50Pure Leaf Unsweetened (18.5oz)
US$3.50Red Bull Energy Drink (8.4oz)
US$4.00S. Pellegrino Sparkling Mineral Water (250ml)
US$4.00Starry (20oz)
US$3.00 My Tomato Pie - Gatorade
Gatorade Fierce Blue Cherry (20oz)
US$4.00Gatorade Gatorlyte Cherry Lime (20oz)
US$5.00Gatorade Gatorlyte Mixed Berry (20oz)
US$5.00Gatorade Gatorlyte Strawberry Kiwi (20oz)
US$5.00Gatorade Gatorlyte Watermelon (20oz)
US$5.00Gatorade Lemon Lime (11.6oz)
US$2.00Gatorade Zero Grape (20oz)
US$4.00Gatorade Zero Lemon Lime (20oz)
US$4.00Gatorade Zero Watermelon Splash (20oz)
US$4.00