Hello dear
Welcome to My Tomato Pie
At My Tomato Pie, we believe in the art of flavor and community. Nestled in Amherst, NY, our establishment offers a delightful blend of classic and innovative dishes, reflecting local tastes and quality. Whether savoring our specialty pizzas, like the Caprese with fresh basil pesto and ripe tomatoes, or indulging in succulent wings with a spectrum of sauces, each bite is crafted with care. Our welcoming atmosphere and dedicated staff enhance your dining experience, making it not just a meal, but a cherished memory. Join us to taste the passion for food that fuels My Tomato Pie, where deliciousness meets warmth.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
Personal Lucca
Small 12" Pizza
Large 16" Pizza
About
My Tomato Pie
Welcome to My Tomato Pie, a hidden gem located at 3055 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst, NY, that promises not only a satisfying meal but a delightful experience. Specializing in comfort food, this eatery offers a diverse menu that guarantees something for everyone, from juicy burgers to delectable seafood. Their welcoming atmosphere, complemented by friendly service, makes this the perfect spot for family dinners, casual outings, or a quick bite during lunch breaks.
Highlights from the Menu:
- Burgers: Sink your teeth into a classic 1/2 pound beef burger topped with American cheese, or try the Bleu Burger for a flavorful twist with smoked bacon and Bleu cheese. The Smokehouse Burger, loaded with BBQ sauce and crispy onion rings, is a must for anyone who craves a hearty bite.
- Seafood: Available only on Wednesdays and Fridays, the beer-battered haddock fish fry is a crowd favorite, served with a side of coleslaw and fries for $19. Don't miss the fish sandwich that's stuffed with fresh, flavorful fillings perfect for seafood lovers.
- Fries and Rings: The Cajun Tossed Fries promise a zesty kick with a savory dry rub, making them the ideal side to complement any main dish.
Customer reviews echo the sentiment of quality and satisfaction. Kevin Smith II enthusiastically raved about the fantastic food and excellent service, calling it a must-visit in the area. Candice echoed similar thoughts, praising the generous portions and delightful flavors of every item she tried.
On my visit, I opted for the Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Sandwich, served on a fresh croissant. The flavors were vibrant, showcasing quality ingredients that truly stood out. The side of crispy fries was just as impressive. The attention to detail, from the packaging to the curbside pickup, added a nice touch to my takeaway experience.
If you're searching for a space that combines delicious food with a cozy atmosphere, My Tomato Pie should be at the top of your list. Whether you’re grabbing a bite during your lunch hour or enjoying a family meal, you’ll leave with satisfied taste buds and wonderful memories. As Sara Reed mentioned, this local spot is a treasure worth revisiting. So, don't miss out — your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Fantastic! Food is perfect for pricing and absolutely delicious! Atmosphere is great as well as waitstaff. Definitely recommended if you're in the area!!! Don't miss out! ”
“ Delicious food! Everything we had was fantastic. The price suits the amount of food you receive. The service was excellent. Will absolutely go back when we are in the area again! ”
“ Ordered for the first time from My Tomato Pie the other day- it is about 2 miles down the street from my office. I ordered the Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad sandwich with fries and it was delicious! It came on a croissant, which was very fresh- you could tell all ingredients in the chicken salad were nice and fresh! The fries were great too! An extra touch that I appreciated were the to-go containers the food came in, something I can save and use in the future and the curb-side pick up was nice as well! I will definetly be returning to try other things on the menu! Love supporting local places with quality ingredients so I'm glad this place did not disappoint! ”
“ A seminar brought us to the restaurant. Not quite sure what to expect of the facility, being in a Top's mall. However, upon entry we were quite pleased. Nice and clean, big entryway. A counter with host to greet and seat. The first room was the banquet room where our seminar was. It was beautifully set up with white table clothes, stem water glasses, cloth napkin wrapped silverware. We were give a choice of three entree items; a chicken salad sandwich, 1/2# cheeseburger, or personal pizza. Here is a review for the two we enjoyed. The 1/2# cheeseburger adorned by a couple nice slices of tomato, lettuce, special sauce on the side. A wonderful spiral pasta mayo salad. The personal pizza, dough was cooked perfectly with a nice crisp on the bottom; yet, soft and enjoyably tender as crust. Just the right amount of tomato sauce, quite deliciously somewhere between sweet and standard. The cheese was just the right quantity, filling dips in the dough for a delicious gooey chew in some places and not others. The pepperoni was charred ever so slightly around the edges, similar to a cup and char, but the slices were larger in diameter and the taste remarkable. A few green olives sprinkled about. Another topping was included if desired. Overall, the meals were very good. The staff was very friendly and polite. Boxes for leftovers brought without needing to ask but not being rushed. The room was quite suited for a small seminar with a nice television for display show. Being the dining room was on the sidewalk side of the building, pull shades made for nice privacy but allowed ample sunlight and viewing to the outside, but not in. Although, we did not eat in the other dining section, which seemed to be the main dining area for the restaurant; it was audible that there is an echo from crowd noise. Those that prefer a quite meal, consider this. The entire facility seemed great for a date or family dining. We would definitely return to the restaurant if in the area. ”
“ There was a bit of a wait tonight, but it was well worth it. Three Tomato Basil soups and a French Onion soup to start. Delicious! If you order anything, order the Tomato soup. The family always look forward to it. The rest of the meal was great as well. Our server was very friendly and quick with the service. ”
“ One of my favorite go tos in the Amherst area. The food is delicious and super consistent (which I think is extremely important for a restaurant), and the menu has a ton of options. It's a very comfortable atmosphere with great service. You won't have a bad meal here! I Highly recommend!!! ”
“ I love my tomato pie I've been going for well over a decade. I first went there when they were still on Sherdian and was happy to see them stay around after whole foods took over. I love their minestrone soup and their pizzas. I hope to be able to go here for many more decades. ”
“ My tomato pie is the place to go for food and drinks. We had Carri for our bartender and she is the absolute best. I requested a strawberry margarita (with my friend) and she made an excellent one, she even crushed up strawberries in it. It was delicious! Her great drink making ability but mainly her kind spirit and on point service on making sure you’re well taken care of is one of the reasons I will keep coming back. The food was also very good as well! ”